A Central New South Wales grain farmer has been handed a $225,000 fine after being convicted of unlawfully clearing almost 950 hectares of native vegetation on his own property — an area roughly equivalent to 570 Sydney Cricket Grounds.
Sheldon Jeffrey Dalton was found guilty by Justice Sarah Pritchard of the NSW Land and Environment Court on two charges relating to the illegal clearing of land on his property, Scotts Craig, at Wallanthery in Central NSW. The clearing took place between May and October 2023, using both fire and machinery.
Threatened Species Habitat Destroyed
Dalton admitted to carrying out the clearing while knowing the property contained native vegetation that served as habitat for the Malleefowl — a stocky, ground-dwelling bird listed as a threatened species. The Malleefowl is roughly the size of a domestic chicken and is distantly related to it.
Justice Pritchard found that Dalton had caused 'actual environmental harm', with the court hearing that vital woodlands and shrubs had been destroyed and the Malleefowl's habitat significantly damaged in the process.
Dalton had engaged a consultant to help draft an invasive native species notification, which was intended to indicate he was clearing invasive plants such as hop bush, turpentine, and cypress pine. However, the court found the clearing went well beyond those species, resulting in broader environmental damage.
Remorse Expressed, But Proof of Regeneration Lacking
Dalton expressed remorse during proceedings, telling the court the charges weighed heavily on both himself and his wife. He noted he had not previously broken environmental laws during his 40 years as a farmer.
He told the court he had made efforts to regenerate the affected areas of his property but was unable to provide photographic evidence of those efforts. Dalton claimed in an affidavit that he had been unable to access the more remote parts of his property due to fears that fugitive murderer Julian Ingram may have been hiding there.
Ingram was wanted by authorities in connection with the deaths of three people — Sophie Quinn, 25, John Harris, 32, and Nerida Quinn, 50 — in nearby Lake Cargelligo in January 2023. Ingram, a council gardener, was missing for more than three months before his body was found in bushland near Eubalong in late May, approximately 75 kilometres northwest of Lake Cargelligo.
'I was told to remain indoors and not to be anywhere in the vicinity,' Dalton wrote in his affidavit.
Fine Designed as a Deterrent
Justice Pritchard made clear that the substantial fine was intended to serve as a deterrent to other landholders who might consider illegal land clearing for commercial gain.
'I am mindful that the sentences imposed should operate as a powerful factor in preventing the commission of similar crimes by those who might otherwise be tempted by the prospect that only a light penalty will be imposed,' she said.
In addition to the $225,000 fine, Dalton was ordered to place advertisements in four newspapers outlining his conviction and the penalty imposed.
The case serves as a significant reminder for landowners across Australia that clearing native vegetation without proper authorisation — even on privately held land — can carry serious legal and financial consequences. Landowners considering any vegetation management work on their properties are strongly encouraged to seek independent legal and environmental advice before proceeding, and to consult with their relevant state authority regarding applicable regulations.
